Category Criminal

Don't talk to the police. Hire a criminal lawyer.

The Right to Remain Silent: Why You Should Talk to Your Lawyer, Not the Police

Imagine this: you’re going about your day when the police approach you. They suspect you of a crime, and suddenly, your world feels like it’s tilting on its axis. You might be tempted to answer their questions, clear your name, and get this over with, but before you speak, here’s a crucial fact to remember, in most jurisdictions, you have the right to remain silent.

This right exists for a reason.  While TV shows often portray suspects readily confessing, the reality is that police questioning can be stressful and confusing.  Even the most innocent details can be misconstrued, and nerves can lead to misunderstandings. Here’s why, when under suspicion, talking to a lawyer is always the smarter first move.

  1. You Might Not Know What You Don’t Know: Police are skilled investigators. They know how to ask leading questions and frame situations in a way that can trip you up. An innocent detail you share could be twisted into an admission of guilt, or you might accidentally provide information that strengthens the case against you.  Your lawyer can advise you on what information is relevant and what’s best left unsaid.

  2. Innocence Doesn’t Guarantee Protection: Being innocent doesn’t mean you’re immune to mistakes.  Under pressure, you might forget a crucial detail that contradicts your story later.  Your lawyer can help you reconstruct your timeline accurately, ensuring your memory is presented clearly.

3.  The Police Aren’t On Your Side (Legally Speaking):  A police officer’s job is to solve crimes, and sometimes, that means building a case against a suspect.  This doesn’t mean they’re out to get you personally, but it’s important to understand their primary objective isn’t to ensure your innocence.  Your lawyer, however, is ethically obligated to protect your rights and advocate for your best interests.

  1. Silence Doesn’t Equal Guilt: In the face of suspicion, some people worry that staying silent will make them look guilty. This simply isn’t true. You have the legal right to remain silent, and exercising that right shouldn’t be misconstrued as an admission of wrongdoing.  Your lawyer can help you politely but firmly assert your right to silence.
  2. Your Words Can Be Used Against You: Anything you say to the police can be used as evidence, even if you’re later arrested on unrelated charges.  Your lawyer can ensure you understand the potential consequences of your words and advise you on how to respond appropriately.

Remember, you are not obligated to answer questions from the police.  If you find yourself under suspicion, here’s what to do:

Be polite but firm. State that you’d like to exercise your right to remain silent and that you want to speak with a lawyer.

Don’t argue or resist. This can escalate the situation.

Contact your lawyer immediately. They can advise you on your next steps and ensure your rights are protected.

We understand that being suspected of a crime is a frightening experience.  But by understanding your right to remain silent and seeking legal counsel immediately, you can protect yourself and ensure a fair outcome.